Power secured, now what about the programme?

Labour Party leader and re-elected Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern claims victory at the Auckland Town Hall .

Phil Walter/Getty Pictures

Labour Social gathering chief and re-elected Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern claims victory on the Auckland City Corridor .

OPINION: In the long run, it was a rout.

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern spent the final 4 weeks portray the nation purple. Rangitata, probably the most conservative citizens within the nation based on Vote Compass, went left and, come the top of the night time, it felt as if the remainder of the nation did too.

Gerry Brownlee, Nationwide’s deputy chief, fell in Ilam. Even the North Shore, the very coronary heart of middle-class consolation and conservatism, took Finance Minister Grant Robertson’s invitation to vote for the celebration that may proceed the John Key and Invoice English legacy – Labour.

And that will get proper to the guts of Labour’s extraordinary victory on Saturday. It was the celebration, to borrow John Key’s favorite phrase, that was robust and steady. Within the closing week Nationwide chief Judith Collins went wildly off message, attacking overweight folks for his or her “selections” and sledging Tasmania for, properly, it wasn’t completely clear. But Jacinda Ardern and her staff have been all poise and dignity compared, repeating the message in each metropolis, city, and again block, that Labour is your finest wager for shielding the nation in opposition to the virus.

What might Nationwide provide as a counter-argument? Collins went onerous and early on a border safety company, however as the times and weeks went on, “border safety” fell away. There isn’t far more a brand new company might do, aside from what’s already taking place. The army is staffing managed isolation services and testing remains to be occurring as new arrivals and returning New Zealanders disembark. A border safety company was nothing greater than a slogan: tough-sounding, virtually Trumpian, however contentless.

It’s price mentioning that this is similar criticism Nationwide made from Labour – that its coverage programme was contentless. Partly, that is true. Ardern dropped any and all guarantees of “transformation”. However on the identical time this was Labour’s power. It had no want for Kiwibuild 2.0, or a agency place on Ihumātao, or a promise to implement the suggestions of its personal welfare working group. New Zealanders have been voting on the final 10 months, we are able to name it the post-Covid second, and every thing that occurred pre-Covid – from the capital good points tax backdown to numerous ministerial embarrassments – didn’t matter.

This was the “Covid election”, as Ardern mentioned on the marketing campaign’s opening.

In the final week of the campaign, National Party leader Judith Collins went wildly off message, Morgan Godfery writes.

Chris McKeen/Stuff

Within the closing week of the marketing campaign, Nationwide Social gathering chief Judith Collins went wildly off message, Morgan Godfery writes.

However that doesn’t clarify the exceptional outcome for the left bloc with the Greens, who no-one can accuse of missing coverage content material, coming in with virtually eight per cent on the night time, taking the left to virtually 60 per cent if you add within the Māori Social gathering’s modest 1 per cent. Is the nation turning into extra progressive? Probably, and also you may argue the excessive turnout and excessive enrolments – particularly amongst Māori – favour the left.

However the reply might be extra prosaic than that. Labour is dominating the centre, taking almost each smooth proper voter and leaving solely the correct’s most conservative base intact, and that just about full spectrum dominance means the left base feels assured {that a} Inexperienced or Māori Social gathering vote ensures, firstly, a Labour-led authorities of 1 type or one other, and secondly, a powerful left opposition to maintain it trustworthy (assuming one or each of the Greens and Māori Social gathering enter opposition).

Columnist Morgan Godfery writes a strong left opposition is essential, “because Labour is possibly hostage to its centrist base”.


Columnist Morgan Godfery writes a powerful left opposition is important, “as a result of Labour is presumably hostage to its centrist base”.

That is important – a powerful left opposition – as a result of Labour is presumably hostage to its centrist base. Some celebration strategists purpose if the celebration strikes too far left its dangers shedding the John Key and Invoice English voters it received this weekend. This implies a left opposition is essential in forcing Labour to fulfil the promise of “transformation” it made in 2017. However even absent that opposition, it’s not as if Labour lacks a mandate for motion. Its majority is unprecedented underneath the MMP electoral system – a outcome that system is designed exactly to stop.

If Labour does nothing with it – failing to behave on local weather change, welfare, tax, housing, and extra – it should have solely itself guilty when voters transfer to events promising extra in 2023.

Leave a Reply